Ok between 4 and 4.5 stars for this one and honestly a fitting end to this series that had me up all night on an emotional roller coaster. I love these characters and getting more from Caleb was so rewarding. I totally felt for him and was left at times picking my jaw off the floor as pieces of the puzzle came together. Some fantastic scenes between him and Olivia and honestly some great interaction between him and Noah. Oh Noah. For me, and I hate admitting this I felt a little something missing in the way of Ole Crazy and Sam. In the end I think it ended as it needed to. This really is a must read! Glad I was on vacation and could consume it all in a matter of days!! Thanks Armina for the recommendation!